Quiet, but not silent switches?

Learning and discussion Key switches
1

So I’ve been trying to choose a switch for my first board. It’s a solder board, I know chances are I will not find my perfect switch right away, but I’d prefer to desolder as little as I can.

I’ve been playing eith the tester and I must say that silent switches (ink silent, boba u4, bobbagum) are all very mushy/rubbery feeling. I was watching this video, and I really liked how quiet these swithces were: Black Jaguar Build Stream - YouTube

They are Tealios switches, and I was wondering if there’s anything similar I can look into, maybe in tactile too. I want a quiet board, but not a silent board. I will lube all my swithces myself so can lube legs to make it more quiet too.

1 Like
2

My current recommendations for silent switches that don’t feel mushy (all come in both linear and tactile):

Kailh midnight pro switches
Epomaker Iceberg Silent
MX Zilent (frankenswitch with MX silent stem in a Zealio housing)

3 Likes
3

Alongside the existing good recommendations, I’d add:

  • TTC Silent Brown V2 (mild tactile)
  • TTC Silent Bluish White (punchy tactile)
  • TTC Frozen Silents (light linear)
  • Momoka Frogs (medium linear)
  • Just about any linear with a fast-curve spring

The first three are silent in terms of having dampeners, but they are not as quiet (or mushy) as Outemu’s or Gateron’s silents - closer to the Kailh Midnight Pros. The Frogs aren’t dampened, but have a mild bottom-out. Fast-curve springs quickly get heavy towards the bottom, which will audibly soften most people’s typing styles.

A few recordings:

Silent Bluish Whites in a dense build (KBD67L):

For comparison, Boba U4s in the same build (KBD67L):

The Skyloongs already mentioned, same build but with taller caps:

Frozen Silents in a hollow build (BBOX60):

Frozen Silents in a dense build (Portico):

Frogs in a moderately dense build (NK65EE):

Fast-curve linears in a small custom 60%:

3 Likes
4

I have to second what was said earlier.

In particular, the TTC Bluish White is already partly silent [on the upstroke], and the TTC Silent Bluish White should be even quieter. Without being a mushy or silent switch.

Also, those new Kailh silent switches are known for being quieter than normal switches, while avoiding mushy dampeners. I tested the Kailh Midnight [original], and that was the case. They are pretty crisp for a “silent” switch, although they are not as silent as the mushy, dampened OUTEMUs. [The mushiness is relative.]

Here’s some info on the Kailh Midnight:

In my experience, Midnights are “quiet” but not “silent” switches, fairly crisp, and deep-sounding. I would get the latest edition, the “Pro.”

You might also want to see this thread:

2 Likes
5

are the Midnight Pros only available from Chosfox? Trying to find an Oz seller…

6

That’s where I got mine. You can also order from Ali express.

1 Like
7

Chosfox had a sale on :wink: and somehow I also ended up buying the Aflion Invokeys Sesame…