Personally, I don’t mind that catering to the color-conscious builder has become JWK’s niche - definitely preferable to their early direction, I think.
So TIL that Nylon is a branded plastic formula within the Polyamide type of plastics - so I’m inferring that these would be Nylon-like bottoms. Is that right?
My guess is that these are indeed nylon. From my understanding, all nylon (which is a brand name by dupont i think) is made from polyamide… but polyamide isn’t necessarily nylon.
Rereading ThereminGoat’s H1 review, he makes a point to mention the distinction between the two.
Polyamides are a larger class of molecules under which Nylon falls. While it is quite similar to Nylon in functionality, it is not technically Nylon for pedantic purposes.
His switch plastics post goes super in depth on those difference. I always end up referring back to this gem when navigating vendor’s bold claims.
@ajoflo do you know if these switches have the new v2 moulds that jwk are using? Moreover, do you know if the description of “custom linear” refers to the use of the H1 moulds? I thought those were only for the H1s? The price seems really good considering they also come with switch films.
Molds aside, I wager these will replicate H1’s stem and housing material, but the verdict is still out on the leaf springs. That’s what I’m looking forward to test the most. Stock H1 springs are buttery heavy, but sort of generic none the less.
Hey thanks for reaching out! I actually do live in the lower mainland but I won’t be getting these. I’m opting to get the new alpaca’s from apex probably.
got these in the mail today. Nice linear switch. I find the spring very comfortably weighted. Not too light and not too heavy. They sound nice. Nothing too high pitched or rattly. Stragely enough, I don’t see a need to film them, even though films were included in the purchase. At least not from the test I did in my M-60A. Perhaps in boards with traditional 1.4mm plates the tops would move more?
There is a hint of friction in the stroke… similar to a gateron switch. However, I find these stock switches to certainly be many steps above something like a KS-8.
Not much else to say. They’re nice. I wouldn’t hesitate to use them stock. I’m sure they would sound top notch with some 205g0. (please note that we are in a global pandemic and I find myself much less picky about switches and such in the past few months. Take all this with a grain of salt)
After placing a lubed SW in a D60 full of lubed tangies, I found that it feels slightly less smooth than the tangerine, but is pretty close. In the sound category, they sound exactly like the tangies, so I guess if you’re looking for a tangies substitute, these would be the way to go.
In the 60 I tested, I found these don’t need films. If that’s the case with all of them, that is a huge bonus. Also, the fact that the factory lube (although thin oil) makes them acceptably smooth stock… These are probably the best overall value JWK linear on the market.
I think it’s how UHMWPE contributes to a higher pitch sound, while Polyamide allows for a bassier one. With nylon, PC, and POM somewhere in the middle.