Initial Impressions
Before I bias myself by reading recent reviews of these switches, I thought Iâd provide my own thoughts on them:
1. HMX Yamatake
Now these are interesting. Mine read âXLLABâ on the housing.
These are a modern Pro Purple, something comparable to AKKOâs P-shaped switches, maybe the Creamy Purple Pro.
They are:
-light-tactiles. Almost down to Brown strength, but still stronger.
-loud. These have a characteristic long-pole tactile sound. Fairly deep.
-âcleanâ - except for the application of factory lubrication, these arenât scratchy, and they donât âcatchâ
I think they also remind me of Gateron Mini i. The Yamatake arenât as crispy and snappy, though. More of a traditional P-shape.
2. HMX Moksae
âSilentâ tactile
These are dampened, medium-tactiles.
Not quite as intense as a proper U4 Boba or Aqua / Crystal Zilent V2.
And not as overpowered silencing as OUTEMU switches [including U4].
Itâs more of a dampener, as in Kailh silents [Deep Sea, in particular].
I feel as though this is an HMX âDeep Sea Whaleâ tactile.
-bump is about that of an Ergo Clear
-but not Cherry-shaped
-lower volume than non-dampened switches, but not âsilentâ
-reasonable housing collisions [or maybe thatâs the dampening]
-low-pitched
-strong medium bump promote staccato typing
Itâs kind of like a snappier, muffled-sounding AKKO Bittersweet.
It also kind of reminds me of TTC Silent Bluish White.
3. HMX Jade
This is a light-medium tactile. Maybe not as strong as Moksae.
The weight reminds me of the stock Gateron Longjing Tea, being seemingly higher than a Brown.
It feels âslowerâ than some other tactiles, due to the spring and tactile stem.
The housing collisions might be a little stiff.
4. AKKO Bittersweet [for comparison]:
-viscous, like pudding
-âsquishy-sounding,â but also relatively quiet
-the stock spring reduces the impact of bottom-out
-aftermarket Geon 50 G 18mm is a great replacement spring
5. HMX LONGJING S
I find this more interesting than most people would. First, I have a board with Gateron Longjing Tea.
This is definitely a light-tactile. Maybe the lighest HMX tactile I tried so far.
The actuation weight is higher than MX Petal, and maybe 10-20% lighter-feeling than HMX K-01.
It is not as loud as HMX Yamatake. That switch has a nice, loud, crisp smack. Just like the sound tests.
The Longjing S, by contrast, is quieter, thinner, and more plasticy-sounding. At least on a Transition Lite TKL.
Itâs basically a switch between MX Petal / Brown and HMX Yamatake. Closer to Yamatake.
Itâs also similar to AKKO Bittersweet, but noticeably lighter than the stock Bittersweet.
I am tempted to fill a whole board with these, but it does have a thin and plasticy sound.
If it werenât for the sound, this could be one of the best light-tactiles.