Okay let’s throw down.
In no particular order we have
-
Which Star Trek Federation Captain would you most want to be on their crew?
-
If you were an ensign, which captain would you want to serve under?
-
Which captain would you want to follow on a deep space exploration mission?
-
Which captain would you want to follow on a diplomacy mission?
-
Which captain would you want to follow into a warzone?
-
If you were a first officer, which captain would you must want to serve under?
-
If you were a captain, which captain’s past self would you want serving under you?
Here are my answers.
-
I would most want to be on Picard’s crew because I think overall he is one of the best when it comes to natural exploration, first contact, and scientific discovery. The crew is pretty well balanced and Galaxy Class Starships are among the best.
-
If I was a plain ensign, It’s hard to say if I’d also want to be on Picard’s crew since I feel like even though he is very balanced and fair, it would be a tough uphill struggle among the best and brightest who have made it onto the Enterprise-D (and later Enterprise-E). As a plain ensign I would actually probably want to be on Sisko’s crew since it would be smaller and I would have a greater impact overall.
-
On a deep space exploration mission I think most would naturally choose Janeway due to her experiences in the Delta Quadrant, or Picard due to his natural love for acheology and appreciation for science. On the other hand if I was stuck far away from home with little or no way to return easily a captain like Sisko may be much more likely to bend the rules because if you judge his willingness to get results (Like in the episode "In the Pale Moonlight S6E19).
-
On a diplomacy mission I would probably want to follow Picard, but following Kirk would probably be the most fun due to his nature.
-
In a warzone, I’d want to follow Kirk or Sisko easily. They can handle themselves in a fight.
-
If I was a first officer, I don’t think I could top Riker, but I’d like to think I could keep up with most of the other first officers. No preferred choice here.
-
Having all of the captain’s in their earlier pre-command years would be an absolutely wonderful team imo. I guess reboot Kirk is out since he never really did anything pre-command. I would possibly want Kirk as he was known to be a tough and very intelligent student instructor. Having someone like that under me to help shape the crew would be wonderful.
How about all of you? Who would you choose?